New Wine for New Hearts

Where We Are

We are in the Second Week of Ordinary Time, moving deeper into the interplay between Israel's first kings and Jesus's early ministry in Galilee. In 1 Samuel, Saul's disobedience meets Samuel's devastating verdict: "Obedience is better than sacrifice." This theme of true versus hollow obedience resonates through the centuries. In Mark's Gospel, Jesus is challenged about fasting and responds with vivid images of new wine and new wineskins. Both readings grapple with the tension between old forms and new realities, between external religious compliance and the interior transformation God truly desires.

The Word

Samuel confronts King Saul for keeping the best of the Amalekite livestock instead of destroying it as God commanded. Saul claims he saved the animals for sacrifice, but Samuel replies, "Does the Lord so delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices as in obedience to the command of the Lord? Obedience is better than sacrifice." Because Saul has rejected God's word, God has rejected him as king. In the Gospel, people ask Jesus why his disciples do not fast like those of John the Baptist and the Pharisees. Jesus answers that wedding guests do not fast while the bridegroom is with them. He adds that no one sews new cloth on an old cloak or pours new wine into old wineskins. New wine requires new wineskins.

Continue Reading

Sign in to read the full devotional and receive it in your inbox each morning - a quiet moment of reflection to start your day.

Send me the daily devotional by email each morning

By signing in, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Reflect

Saul's failure is a masterclass in religious self-deception. He does the wrong thing and dresses it in spiritual language: "I kept the animals for sacrifice." It sounds pious, but Samuel sees through it immediately. God did not ask for sacrifice; God asked for obedience. The distinction matters enormously. Sacrifice lets us choose what to give God on our own terms. Obedience requires us to give God what he actually asks for, even when it is uncomfortable.

Jesus takes this further with the wineskin metaphor. The old wineskins represent religious structures that have become rigid and unable to contain the new reality of the Kingdom. Fasting was a good practice, but when Jesus, the bridegroom, is present, a new response is required. The point is not that fasting is wrong but that clinging to old forms without understanding their purpose leads to spiritual rigidity.

This is a perennial challenge. Every generation faces the temptation to confuse tradition with traditionalism, to mistake the wineskin for the wine. The wine is always the presence of God, the living relationship with Christ. The wineskins are the forms and structures that contain it. When the forms become more important than the presence, something has gone wrong.

The invitation of Ordinary Time is to become new wineskins, flexible, humble, and ready to be expanded by whatever God pours into us next.

Living It

Examine one spiritual practice you do regularly: prayer, Mass attendance, Bible reading, volunteering. Are you going through the motions, or are you encountering God in it? If it has become rigid, ask God to make it new.

Saul chose sacrifice over obedience because sacrifice was easier. Is there an area in your life where God is asking for simple obedience, but you keep substituting something more comfortable? Name it and take one step of obedience today.

Jesus called himself the bridegroom. Let this reframe your understanding of faith: it is not primarily about rules and obligations but about a relationship with someone who loves you. Approach today as a guest at a wedding feast, with gratitude and joy.

Prayer

Lord, forgive us for the times we have offered you sacrifice when you were asking for obedience. Forgive us for clinging to old wineskins when you are pouring new wine. Make our hearts flexible enough to receive what you are doing today. Help us release the forms that no longer serve the relationship and embrace the new ways you are making yourself known. You are the bridegroom. Teach us to rejoice in your presence. Amen.